Which Mama Mia! movie is better?
Click an image or button below to vote!
One gave us the original Greek-island getaway, unforgettable ABBA hits, and a wedding full of surprises. The other took us back in time to discover Donna's story and brought even more music and emotion.
Mamma Mia! Released in 2008, Mamma Mia! brought ABBA's biggest hits to a sunny Greek island for a musical filled with romance, friendship, and family secrets. The story follows Sophie, a young woman preparing for her wedding who secretly invites three men from her mother's past, hoping to discover which one is her father. With Meryl Streep as Donna, Amanda Seyfried as Sophie, and an ensemble cast full of memorable performances, the movie became a feel-good favorite. From “Dancing Queen” to “The Winner Takes It All,” its soundtrack helped turn the film into a sing-along classic. Between the beautiful scenery, hilarious moments, and emotional mother-daughter relationship, the original Mamma Mia! captured a special kind of movie magic that fans continue to revisit.
Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again The 2018 sequel, Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again, returned audiences to the Greek island for another round of music, romance, and family connections. This time, the story moves between the present and the past, revealing how a young Donna, played by Lily James, met the three men who would eventually become part of Sophie's life. While Sophie prepares to reopen the hotel her mother dreamed of, the film explores love, independence, friendship, and the people who shape our lives. Alongside returning favorites, new faces and fresh performances bring additional energy to the story. With songs like “Waterloo” and “Fernando,” the sequel expands the original's world while delivering its own emotional moments. For many fans, it's more than a follow-up—it's a chance to experience the magic all over again.
