Who is the more iconic comedic actress?
Click an image or button below to vote!
Amy Schumer and Melissa McCarthy are two of the best comedians around, but fans only debate which of these two is a more iconic artist. Amy Schumer broke onto the scene with unapologetic stand-up, acerbic social critique, and her highest-rated show Inside Amy Schumer, offering mass comedy a raw, unfiltered voice. Melissa McCarthy, meanwhile, was propelled into the mainstream with her breakthrough role in Bridesmaids and a string of sidesplitting performances in Spy and The Heat. Her physical comedy and larger-than-life personas have netted her laughs and approving nods of critics, including an Oscar nomination. Both have rewritten what constitutes a comedic leading lady in Hollywood. Whether you love Schumer's acerbic, no-holds-barred style or McCarthy's off-the-wall, attention-grabbing exuberance, it's clear both have had a lasting impact on comedy.
Melissa McCarthyMelissa McCarthy is a profoundly gifted American actress, comedian, writer, and producer, well known for her diverse performances and singular brand of humor. Born on 26 August 1970 in Plainfield, Illinois, McCarthy began her career in stand-up and improv, famously becoming a graduate of The Groundlings comedy troupe.
She first gained fame as Sookie St. James in the hit television show Gilmore Girls (2000–2007). Her big break came when she acted in the critically and commercially successful comedy film Bridesmaids (2011), which earned her an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actress. She became one of the top comedic performers at that time.
McCarthy's TV success was then followed by the sitcom Mike & Molly (2010–2016), which won her a Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series. Her filmography includes a string of box office hits in the comedy genre, such as Identity Thief (2013), The Heat (2013), and Spy (2015), where she proved herself at integrating physical comedy with good character acting. A departure from her typical comedic acting, she was nominated for a second Academy Award, this time as Best Actress, for her intense dramatic performance in Can You Ever Forgive Me? (2018). She most recently thrilled fans as Ursula in Disney's live-action adaptation of The Little Mermaid (2023) and appeared in Only Murders in the Building (2024).
Melissa McCarthy has been praised for her fearless approach to character acting, often playing roles that defy the usual female comedy types, and her incredible ability to induce both sidesplitting laughter and nuanced emotional depth.
She first gained fame as Sookie St. James in the hit television show Gilmore Girls (2000–2007). Her big break came when she acted in the critically and commercially successful comedy film Bridesmaids (2011), which earned her an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actress. She became one of the top comedic performers at that time.
McCarthy's TV success was then followed by the sitcom Mike & Molly (2010–2016), which won her a Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series. Her filmography includes a string of box office hits in the comedy genre, such as Identity Thief (2013), The Heat (2013), and Spy (2015), where she proved herself at integrating physical comedy with good character acting. A departure from her typical comedic acting, she was nominated for a second Academy Award, this time as Best Actress, for her intense dramatic performance in Can You Ever Forgive Me? (2018). She most recently thrilled fans as Ursula in Disney's live-action adaptation of The Little Mermaid (2023) and appeared in Only Murders in the Building (2024).
Melissa McCarthy has been praised for her fearless approach to character acting, often playing roles that defy the usual female comedy types, and her incredible ability to induce both sidesplitting laughter and nuanced emotional depth.
Amy SchumerAmy Schumer is an American stand-up comedian, actress, writer, producer, and director who is renowned for her bold, often profane, and self-deprecating comedy. Born on June 1, 1981, in New York City, Schumer gained popularity in the comedy world during the early 2000s and rose to national fame after appearing on NBC's Last Comic Standing in 2007.
She landed her breakthrough role with the critically acclaimed sketch comedy series Inside Amy Schumer, which premiered on Comedy Central in 2013. The show emphasized her sharp wit, tackling topics like sex, relationships, and women's social expectations with a smart combination of observational humor and incisive satire. Inside Amy Schumer won a Peabody Award and an Emmy Award for Outstanding Variety Sketch Series in 2015.
Schumer also solidified her comedy star with her starring and screenwriting debut in the 2015 Judd Apatow smash Trainwreck, earning a Golden Globe nomination. She continued to star in films like Snatched (2017) and I Feel Pretty (2018), and venture into more intimate storytelling with the HBO documentary series Expecting Amy (2020) and Hulu comedy-drama series Life & Beth (2022-2024).
Her stand-up specials, including Mostly Sex Stuff, Live at the Apollo, Growing, and Emergency Contact, regularly break barriers, rendering her the go-to name for fearless and relatable comedy. Beyond entertainment, Schumer is also an outspoken proponent of gun control and mental health awareness, often incorporating these personal experiences and social observations into her work.
She landed her breakthrough role with the critically acclaimed sketch comedy series Inside Amy Schumer, which premiered on Comedy Central in 2013. The show emphasized her sharp wit, tackling topics like sex, relationships, and women's social expectations with a smart combination of observational humor and incisive satire. Inside Amy Schumer won a Peabody Award and an Emmy Award for Outstanding Variety Sketch Series in 2015.
Schumer also solidified her comedy star with her starring and screenwriting debut in the 2015 Judd Apatow smash Trainwreck, earning a Golden Globe nomination. She continued to star in films like Snatched (2017) and I Feel Pretty (2018), and venture into more intimate storytelling with the HBO documentary series Expecting Amy (2020) and Hulu comedy-drama series Life & Beth (2022-2024).
Her stand-up specials, including Mostly Sex Stuff, Live at the Apollo, Growing, and Emergency Contact, regularly break barriers, rendering her the go-to name for fearless and relatable comedy. Beyond entertainment, Schumer is also an outspoken proponent of gun control and mental health awareness, often incorporating these personal experiences and social observations into her work.
